Page 1 of 4
Best Static mobile antenna?
Posted: Wed May 20, 2009 8:15 pm
by nato 2000
Helloo all, im really intrested in buying a antenna purely for when static mobile and ive been thinking of either a 1/4wave tank whip or a sirio 4000, just wanting some comments about these two antenna's and any other one's you lot could recommend to me, im also intrested in buying a GP kit for the car aswell but not sure where to start with them, if there worth the money and if they actually work in producing an omnidirectional antenna? Many thanks!! scott.
Re: Best Static mobile antenna?
Posted: Wed May 20, 2009 10:25 pm
by Offplanet
I get out well on a 7ft Thunderpole ThunderStick static mobile (like a Firestick) - I also use a Thunderpole Tri-Star to improve the radiation pattern as the my 3/8 mount is installed towards the rear of the vehicle (helps with the SWR too).
Cheers.
Re: Best Static mobile antenna?
Posted: Wed May 20, 2009 11:08 pm
by nato 2000
Thanks for the quick reply, im really thinking of buying a tank whip due to it being a full 1/4 wave, one thing id like to ask you though is was there a noticible inprovment to the rx and tx when using the tri star? or did it just help with the swr? thanks bud.
Re: Best Static mobile antenna?
Posted: Wed May 20, 2009 11:16 pm
by marsh phantom
i use a tank whip, mag mounted also with the tristar, it drops the swr a touch, not sure how much it inproves the radiation pattern but you could always make your own gp with some tubing utilising the tristar center just make your own radials.
i have not really noticed a diference with the tristar on with tx or rx, they do sell a 6 radial version on a certain auction site but again only small radials
Re: Best Static mobile antenna?
Posted: Wed May 20, 2009 11:29 pm
by Offplanet
There's a SWR improvement for sure - as far as radiation pattern is concerned, probably/maybe but I'd have to do some more tests to be sure (only used it a few times so far on the van).
Re: Best Static mobile antenna?
Posted: Wed May 20, 2009 11:36 pm
by nato 2000
marsh phantom wrote:i use a tank whip, mag mounted also with the tristar, it drops the swr a touch, not sure how much it inproves the radiation pattern but you could always make your own gp with some tubing utilising the tristar center just make your own radials.
i have not really noticed a diference with the tristar on with tx or rx, they do sell a 6 radial version on a certain auction site but again only small radials
Hmmm i think ive worked out the correct length radials for a tank whip would be 20.4" long? either that or 12.75" im not that sure really as ive just really got into cb so currently reading my way through some intresting things about patterns etc. thanks for the info though mate!
Re: Best Static mobile antenna?
Posted: Wed May 20, 2009 11:40 pm
by nato 2000
Offplanet wrote:There's a SWR improvement for sure - as far as radiation pattern is concerned, probably/maybe but I'd have to do some more tests to be sure (only used it a few times so far on the van).
Righht, its a worth while buy if my swr's slightly up then i guess, from what ive read i know that due to antenna's being different lengths the radials would need to be suited to each antenna so surely the tri star is just a compromise making it a slight inprovement? Dont count me on that mind as im still learning

Re: Best Static mobile antenna?
Posted: Wed May 20, 2009 11:45 pm
by marsh phantom
i can tell you that on my tristar the lengh of the radials are 3.5inch (this is how it came)
Re: Best Static mobile antenna?
Posted: Wed May 20, 2009 11:53 pm
by nato 2000
marsh phantom wrote:i can tell you that on my tristar the lengh of the radials are 3.5inch (this is how it came)
Really! Hmm thats intresting im suprised it altered much atall, i thought they were about 12inches each from the pics

well thanks for that, i'll have to do some more revision and try and make my own gp kit. One thing i know i will be stuck on is how to mount it on to the tank whip itself? Where the 3/8fitting is id guess. thanks again.
Re: Best Static mobile antenna?
Posted: Thu May 21, 2009 12:01 am
by marsh phantom
you could buy a tristar and ditch the original radials as they are removed by unscrewing them (they are a 3/8th screw) and just use the center that way just make your own raials with a 3/8th screw on and your away
Re: Best Static mobile antenna?
Posted: Thu May 21, 2009 12:03 am
by Offplanet
I maybe wrong but the ends of the radials look like wound coils - all I know is the SWR is down, and if the guy at the other end can hear me better with the Tri-Star, then it's a few quid well spent.
Worth a try is all I can say

Re: Best Static mobile antenna?
Posted: Thu May 21, 2009 12:19 am
by nato 2000
marsh phantom wrote:you could buy a tristar and ditch the original radials as they are removed by unscrewing them (they are a 3/8th screw) and just use the center that way just make your own raials with a 3/8th screw on and your away
Sounds like a plan i think as they are pretty cheap, just got to work out exactly how long the radials are meant to be for a 1/4wave antenna now somehow

cheers.
Re: Best Static mobile antenna?
Posted: Thu May 21, 2009 12:20 am
by marsh phantom
yer they are cheap enough to have a mess about with, just keep an eye on that swr
Re: Best Static mobile antenna?
Posted: Thu May 21, 2009 5:27 pm
by nato 2000
Yeah will do! thanks again bud.
Re: Best Static mobile antenna?
Posted: Fri May 22, 2009 5:17 pm
by porky.69
i take the antron 99 now its so easy to set up and take down and it works brill
